Rosenberg: Ukraine Is Under Attack, Their People Are Dying & Trump Wants Something In Return | MSNBC

Rosenberg: Ukraine Is Under Attack, Their People Are Dying & Trump Wants Something In Return | MSNBC 1


Chuck Rosenberg, Nicolle Wallace, Brian Williams, George Conway and Neal Katyal discuss the toll halting security assistance would have on the Ukrainian people. Aired on 11/13/19.
» Subscribe to MSNBC:

MSNBC delivers breaking news, in-depth analysis of politics headlines, as well as commentary and informed perspectives. Find video clips and segments from The Rachel Maddow Show, Morning Joe, Meet the Press Daily, The Beat with Ari Melber, Deadline: White House with Nicolle Wallace, Hardball, All In, Last Word, 11th Hour, and more.

Connect with MSNBC Online
Subscribe to MSNBC Newsletter:
Find MSNBC on Facebook:
Follow MSNBC on Twitter:
Follow MSNBC on Instagram:

Rosenberg: Ukraine Is Under Attack, Their People Are Dying & Trump Wants Something In Return | MSNBC

90 Comments on "Rosenberg: Ukraine Is Under Attack, Their People Are Dying & Trump Wants Something In Return | MSNBC"

  1. Mango Mussolini | November 13, 2019 at 3:03 PM | Reply

    Do not respond directly to the trolls it’s how they get paid. The following are known russian trolls:

    William H
    Dicky Jones
    Janet Masiello
    Janet Airlines
    Irish Buck
    Jeffrey Meade

    Please give this a thumbs up so that everyone sees this list and stop feeding the trolls. Feel free to copy and paste on every political video.

  2. BundesRepublic Murica | November 13, 2019 at 3:04 PM | Reply

    Love George Conway and that is hard for me because I think most conservatives are radioactive. Who knew one could have his head screwed on straight.

    • TheArozconpollo | November 13, 2019 at 3:57 PM | Reply

      George doesn’t seem to buy-in on the conspiracy theories that plague the minds of most conservatives.

    • Devin Nunes is so toxic that the GOP brought in a pedophile apologist, Jim Jordan to be their spokesperson on the Impeachment hearing.

      So mount an affirmative defense, Trump Supporters.

      Let’s hear the evidence Republicans. Let us hear from the defendant *DIRECTLY*.

      I want testimony . . . under oath from

      – Trump
      – Pompeo
      – Guiliani
      – Sonderland
      – Volker
      – Perry

      If the call was so perfect, defend it directly and aggressively.

      That’s what an innocent man . . . who truly believes in Law & Order . . . would do.

    • Verum illic – well said!

    • It beats me that he can even tolerate his wife…………….must have the patience of a saint as well as all that legal acumen.

  3. Daniel Duvalle | November 13, 2019 at 3:05 PM | Reply

    Let’s not forget, Trump deserves impeachment for his effect on US national security alone. And it should be made perfectly clear: Any seditious cultists threatening civil war or violence if Trump is impeached or isn’t reelected are promoting domestic terrorism and deserve to be persecuted with extreme prejudice.

    “Trump Cited As A Motivating Factor In 81 Murders And 7 Terrorist Plots”

    “Domestic Terrorism. Domestic terrorists—a phrase typically used to denote terrorists who are not directed or inspired by FTOs—have caused more deaths in the United States in recent years than have terrorists connected to FTOs. Domestic terrorist attacks and hate crimes sometimes overlap, as perpetrators of prominent domestic terrorist attacks have selected their targets based on factors such as race, ethnicity, national origin, religion, sexual orientation, gender, and gender identity.

    White supremacist violent extremism, one type of racially- and ethnically-motivated violent extremism, is one of the most potent forces driving domestic terrorism. Lone attackers, as opposed to cells or organizations, generally perpetrate these kinds of attacks. But they are also part of a broader movement. White supremacist violent extremists’ outlook can generally be characterized by hatred for immigrants and ethnic minorities, often combining these prejudices with virulent anti-Semitism or anti-Muslim views.

    White supremacist violent extremists have adopted an increasingly transnational outlook in recent years, largely driven by the technological forces described earlier in this Strategic Framework. Similar to how ISIS inspired and connected with potential radical Islamist terrorists, white supremacist violent extremists connect with like-minded individuals online. In addition to mainstream social media platforms, white supremacist violent extremists use lesser-known sites like Gab, 8chan, and EndChan, as well as encrypted channels. Celebration of violence and conspiracy theories about the “ethnic replacement” of whites as the majority ethnicity in various
    Western countries are prominent in their online circles. ”

    • Michael bagley | November 13, 2019 at 6:56 PM | Reply

      @Dmitri Fukov No, that is incorrect. Your President (45), Faux Entertainment, Hannity, Alex Jones, and Brietbart have cornered the market on both bogus and debunked conspiracy therories as well as fake news. In fact, if they gave out Academy Awards for bogus conspiracy therories and fake news, 45 and his conservative syncophants would win a truck full of fake gold Oscars.

    • @car. A Really? That’s an interesting thought.

    • Just WOW!🙄

    • Are you sure that the one link is correct in what it claims or are there other resources that will collaborate what they are claiming? How about rioters protesting trump winning the election and attacking police, destroying business’s windows and ransacking the buildings and the streets? How about the guy that started shooting at Republican senators at a baseball field almost killing one of them? how about the 4 teenagers that kidnapped and tortured for 3 days a handicap kid because Trump won the election while live streaming it? or the people attacking cars that have Trump stickers? See it’s easy to point the finger and blame some one for other peoples actions. My question is when are you and others going to let those people take responsibility for their own actions and not blame it on a person or a video?

  4. Am so proud of Kent and Taylor! 💙

  5. Alfred Basurto | November 13, 2019 at 3:06 PM | Reply

    Trump cares about Trump. Trump supporters need to remember that when he spews patriotism and loving America. Trump loves nobody but himself. Its impossible to love anyone else with his type of character.

    • Republicans don’t care.

    • They think they are patriot, but they never been patriot. NO true patriot and NO true Christian stand for what’s going on for past 2yrs. Country above self interest.

    • Who could it be….??? SATAN?

    • Alfred Basurto | November 13, 2019 at 9:55 PM | Reply

      @Aranyani Fox you hit the nail on the head. The pushing of propaganda, conspiracy, fascism, nationalism, divorced reality, and thinking with emotion is staggering. Republicans should be ashamed and see they are actually in a conspiracy theory themselves. Against them. Designed to keep them stupid and uninformed. Designed against them and making them unintentionally look stupid and on purpose stupid. They should be angry that their own party treats them like this. The only irony is they are part of a conspiracy against themselves put on them by their own political party of choice. Its disgusting to watch. I feel bad for them.

  6. GILBERT Hernandez | November 13, 2019 at 3:13 PM | Reply

    Republicans are twisting, and getting off the subject on hearing. Dogs

  7. Trump declared war on the west, bowing for his chief Putin.

    • Dave Salimeno – I was asking you a serious question, and deserved a serious answer, not a deflection. You maintain the muller enquiry found no collusion. But rick gates testimony showed trump lied. I suppose I was merely pointing out that there are things still to come out in roger stones trial, as there will be when Barr finishes his investigation.

    • D SP – great post. Explains it clearly. I just assumed trump had lied to muller, but nice to get confirmation.

    • Aerial Relaxation Films | November 13, 2019 at 8:02 PM | Reply

      As Drump bent over told Putin to please give it to him without any Vaseline. LMFAO

    • Dave Salimeno …have a wodka and go to bed, Igor🇷🇺

  8. I’ll never understand how George Conway can stand being married to vile KellyAnne, they are polar opposites

    • @QuasiELVIS what was her title before Trump? Like when she used to appear at Bill Maker’s…?, ‘Republican Pollster’ Its much more than ‘a VERY good paying job’: WH experience, name recognition and a place in the circle of conservative BS politics, where tons of money is available for those willing to debase themselves enough. And that she is playing an act with regard to Trump doesn’t mean she doesn’t believe she’s advancing republican policy. Probably has awful opinions of her own. Same for Pence and other religious nutcases around him, whom believe they are somehow doing god’s work because they are stuffing the SC with like-minded bigots.
      But it’s worth saying here too that her husband is also a hypocrite.

    • @Gimme A Break so you are a republican and she is the loon? That’s a ‘quaint’ adjetive, fit for a democrat, which you would never use on a republican, where ‘deranged’ would be more proper…

    • who cares?

    • @Dulcie Gray apparently you, since you are here commenting…

    • Kenneth R Loper | November 16, 2019 at 4:33 PM | Reply

      I know right 😎 I bet you they don’t even talk to each other day just yell at one another

  9. Chris Deschenes | November 13, 2019 at 3:19 PM | Reply

    Trump: To Ukraine —–> Lie or die !!

    • @ღSwnsasyღ _ It’s perfectly ok to lie and people die as long as it serves Israeli interest, remember that.

    • ღSwnsasyღ _ | November 15, 2019 at 5:12 AM | Reply

      ZeroNadaZilch I think you’re commenting the WRONG person! I never said anything that you’re talking about .. I’m 100 % with you about Venezuela and Iran, I’m right there.. How can you go off on me about a topic NEVER raised in my response back to the commentor??? Did you think I was psychic and just KNEW I should change topic and talk about what you said?? You owe me an apology for what you said. Either wrong person you’re talking to our you’re seeing things in a message that just isn’t there.

    • Ukraine has been dying since 1986 with Chernobyl, Trump dating and schmoozing and putzing at that time, so yes he probably was lying. I don’t care, I despise liars then this is really no change from him only We as taxpayers have to see his carnival, not very Presidential that.

    • @Joan Cote seeing you made this claim what did he do that is treason? Or do you have no facts to back it up and are just making a statement of opinion?

    • @ღSwnsasyღ _ So with your statement then it was Obama’s fault that the Kurds suffered massive casualty’s when in 2015 he brought them in to fight the war on ISIS? or how about before that when Turkey kept attacking the Kurds believing them to be terrorist. Granted Turkey did the same under Trump when he left them to fighting the remaining ISIS but immediately withdrew attacking the Kurds once the US stepped back in and forced them to back down. Now as for the help you claimed they died waiting for you know it takes a year believe it or not to send that aid to them. So regardless of when the aid is released it will still take one year to get it to them. It’s not like the US has the promised supplies laying around just eager to be deployed.

  10. Nicolle Wallace has did some outstanding reporting over recent times. The same goes for Rachel Maddow and Ari Melber and all the morning Joe team. Great work MSNBC

    • @Joanne Park they only speak to those that listen who share the same ideology as them. Remember half the country voted for Trump there for Fox News that was created in the 1980’s because of the media being bias and leaning only to democratic party speaks to the other half of the country that do not fit your ideology.

    • @Terry Hawkins i don’t think Trump is an extension of their actions. If you look at it he helped expose them and their racist rot and bigotry. The Democratic party and their supporters…. So caring, So empathetic, So compassionate, So understanding… Until they lose or don’t get their way then its burn it all down, Republicans are the racist even thou were the ones attacking people and destroying streets because he made us do it by winning. This is why the forefathers warned the nation never to split into a 2 party system. The government is designed to work for the country and not have political differences because they knew back then a nation divided is not a nation at all. It lead to the Civil War of 1861 to 1865 and soon will lead to another one if people don’t start cooperating again and working together rather then politically dividing. ‘Those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it.’ (George Santayana-1905). In a 1948 speech to the House of Commons, Winston Churchill changed the quote slightly when he said (paraphrased), ‘Those who fail to learn from history are condemned to repeat it.’

    • Thats not funny | November 18, 2019 at 4:42 PM | Reply

      Ryan Odonnel
      I agree.

    • Lol are you delusional? Maddow is a conspiracy theory drunkard

  11. It’s not bribery, offering money or military aid to Ukraine for personal benefit. It’s extortion, withholding much needed, life and liberty saving, already approved US taxpayer funded military aid for personal benefit.

  12. Trump is a criminal and has to be removed and punished for violating the constitution of the United states.

  13. I salute these patriots; Kent and Bill and those coming forward in the coming days to tell the truth and uphold the constitutions and our rules and laws

    You are America Heroes!!!!

  14. When you have a draft dodging coward for a fake president this is to be expected.

    • @Tom Maynardbla bla Clinton doesn’t disprove anything…Trump used the same deferments fur school and two doctors diagnosed his feet….just like Clinton and Biden….bla bla you.

    • @Jim myz excusing your man by pointing at someone else’s excuses is typical cultist, my friend your adoration is touching. Unfortunately thought it changes nothing, your man is a coward.

    • @Tom Maynard again with the ad hominems…Trump used the same things afforded to him as did anyone before him who “isn’t a coward” in your eyes. He’s not my “man” I didn’t vote for him, but he is “our” man…sorry you can hate the man but you can’t hate the position, remind us again who put him there? And in 2020 when he wins the election again, and sorry your Cult Indoctrination fallacy? “Cults are populated by people just like you.” You hate the President, you hate me, you hate the 74% of registered voters who did not vote for your candidate. Yeah math sucks……and facts are not on your side.

    • What was it that he said? Oh yes – that non-Trumpers are human scum!! Well whatever your destiny is Donnie – The whole world is watching (as is your child Baron) he is going to have to live with your vile corruptions for the rest of his life – poor kid!!

  15. to paraphrase JFK

    Trump: ” Ask not what you can do for your country, ask what you can do for ME “

  16. Benjamin Miiller | November 13, 2019 at 3:33 PM | Reply

    Drumph could care less who dies, while he lies. Apparently the republicants don’t care either.

  17. Article II, Section 4 provides:

    The President, Vice President and all civil Officers of the United States, shall be REMOVED from Office on Impeachment for, and Conviction of, Treason, BRIBERY, or other high Crimes and Misdemeanors.


    English oxford dictionary
    Noun 1. bribery – the practice of offering something (usually money) in order to gain an illicit advantage-bribery – the practice of offering something

    bribe (braib) noun 2.
    a gift offered to persuade a person to do something, usually dishonest

  18. No Justice Just Us | November 13, 2019 at 3:53 PM | Reply

    The insincere antics of Jim Jordan and Devin Nunes are gonna be hard to watch… You’re a brave man George Conway… The future of The United States of America and in fact the whole world are the stakes here.

  19. Patrick Kennedy | November 13, 2019 at 4:31 PM | Reply

    A president is impeachable if he attempts to subvert the Constitution. – James Madison

  20. “In return” for something that isn’t his, and that he had no authority to withhold.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published.


This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.